• .
    Mais informações

    Relatórios de analistas

    Blog

    Brochures

    Checklist

    Casos de sucesso

    Datasheets

    Aprender

    eBooks

    Infografias

    Notícias

    White Paper

    Contacto

    Seminários on-line

    Eventos

    Comércio autónomo

    ESG

    Sobre nós

    Plataforma JAGGAER One

    Carreiras

    Conformidade e Segurança

    Casos de sucesso

    Support

    Partner Marketplace

    Torne-se um parceiro

    Por indústria

    Educação

    Fabricação

    Energia y Utilidades

    Serviços Financeiros

    Cuidados de saúde

    Ciências da Vida e Farmacêutica

    Por indústria

    Retalho

    CPG

    Setor público

    Transporte e Logística

    Por função

    Compras

    Finanças

    Tecnologia da Informação

    Cadeia de fornecimento

    Por necessidade

    IA em compras

    Redução de custos

    Aquisição Direta

    ESG

    Integração com outros sistemas empresariais

    Rentabilidade das compras

    Otimização de fornecimento

    Visibilidade das despesas

    Cumprimento dos fornecedores

    Aprender

    Informes de analistas

    Blog

    Brochures

    Checklist

    Casos de éxito

    Datasheets

    Aprender

    eBooks

    Infografías

    Noticias

    White Paper

    Contacto

    Webinars

    Eventos

    Comercio Autónomo

    ESG

    Acerca de

    Plataforma JAGGAER One

    Carreras

    Cumplimiento y seguridad

    Historias de éxito

    Soporte

    Partner Marketplace

    Conviértete en partner

    Por industria

    Educación

    Manufacturing

    Energía y Utilities

    Servicios financieros

    Sanidad

    Farmacéutico y Ciencias de la vida

    Por industria

    Retail

    Bienes de consumo envasados

    Sector Público

    Transporte y Logística

    Por función

    Compras

    Finanzas

    Tecnologías de la información

    Cadena de suministro

    Por necesidad

    IA en compras

    Reducción de costes

    Compras directas

    Criterios ESG

    Integración con otros sistemas empresariales

    Rentabilidad de compras

    Optimización de compras

    Visibilidad del gasto

    Compliance de Proveedores

    Scopri di più

    Analyst Reports

    Blog

    Brochure

    Checklists

    I nostri clienti. Storie di successo

    Datasheets

    Imparare

    eBooks

    Infographics

    News

    White Paper

    Contattaci

    Webinar

    Eventi

    Autonomous Commerce

    ESG

    Chi siamo

    La piattaforma JAGGAER One

    Lavora con noi

    Compliance & Security

    Storie di successo

    Servizio Clienti

    Partner Marketplace

    Diventa Partner

    Per settore

    Education

    Manufacturing

    Energy and Utilities

    Financial Services

    Healthcare

    Life Sciences and Pharmaceuticals

    Per settore

    Retail

    Consumer Packaged Goods (CPG)

    Settore pubblico e regolamentato

    Trasporti e logistica

    Per funzione

    Procurement

    Finance

    IT

    Supply Chain

    Per necessità

    AI nel Procurement

    Riduzione dei costi

    Direct Procurement

    Obiettivi ESG

    Integrazione nell'ecosistema aziendale

    Procurement Profitability

    Sourcing Optimization

    Spend Visibility

    Supplier Compliance

    Success stories

    Service client

    Erfolgsgeschichten

    Kundensupport

    Lernen

    Analyst Reports

    Blog

    Broschüren

    Checklisten

    Kundenerfolgsgeschichten

    Produktflyer

    Lernen

    E-Books

    Infografiken

    News

    Whitepaper

    Verbinden

    Webinare

    Veranstaltungen

    Autonomous Commerce

    ESG

    Über uns

    Die Platform

    Karriere

    Compliance und Sicherheit

    Partner Marketplace

    Partner werden

    Nach Branche

    Bildungswesen

    Fertigende Unternehmen

    Energie und Versorgung

    Finanzdienstleistungen

    Gesundheitspflege

    Biowissenschaften und Pharmazeutik

    Nach Branche

    Einzelhandel

    Consumer Packaged Goods (CPG)

    Öffentlicher Sektor

    Transport und Logistik

    Nach Rolle

    Beschaffung

    Finanzen

    Informationstechnologie

    Lieferkette

    Nach Bedarf

    KI im Einkauf

    Kostenreduzierung

    Direkter Einkauf

    ESG-Ziel

    Integration in die Geschäftssystemlandschaft

    Beschaffungsrentabilität

    Beschaffungsoptimierung

    Ausgabentransparenz

    Lieferanten-Compliance

    Marketplace des partenaires

    Devenir un partenaire

    Ressources utiles

    Rapports d'analystes

    Blog

    Brochures

    Checklist

    Témoignages de nos clients

    Datasheets

    Learn

    eBooks

    Infographies

    Actualités

    Livres blancs

    Nous rencontrer

    Webinaires

    Événements

    Commerce autonome

    ESG

    À propos

    La plateforme

    Emplois

    Conformité et sécurité

    Par industrie

    Éducation

    Fabrication

    Énergie et Utilities

    Services financiers

    Santé

    Sciences de la vie et produits pharmaceutiques

    Par industrie

    Retail

    Consumer Packaged Goods (CPG)

    Secteur public

    Transport et logistique

    Par département

    Achats

    Finance

    Informatique

    Supply Chain

    Par besoin

    L'IA dans les achats

    Réduction des coûts

    Achats directs

    Objectif ESG

    Intégration dans le paysage des systèmes d'entreprise

    Rentabilité des achats

    Optimisation du Sourcing

    Visibilité des dépenses

    Conformité des fournisseurs

    Learn

    Analyst Reports

    Blog

    Brochures

    Checklists

    Customer Success Stories

    Datasheets

    Learn

    eBooks

    Infographics

    News

    White Paper

    Connect

    Webinars

    Events

    REV Events

    About

    ESG

    Autonomous Commerce

    JAGGAER One Platform

    Careers

    Compliance & Security

    Success Stories

    Customer Support

    Partner Marketplace

    Become a Partner

    By Industry

    Education

    Manufacturing

    Energy and Utilities

    Financial Services

    Healthcare

    Life Sciences and Pharmaceuticals

    By Industry

    Retail

    Consumer Packaged Goods

    Public Sector

    Transportation and Logistics

    By Role

    Procurement

    Finance

    IT

    Supply Chain

    By Need

    AI in Procurement

    Cost Reduction

    Direct Procurement

    ESG Goal

    Integration into Business System Landscape

    Procurement Profitability

    Sourcing Optimization

    Spend Visibility

    Supplier Compliance

    Blog

    A Resolution to the Classic End-to-End vs. Best-in-Class Debate

    Procure to Pay | Source to Pay

    I’ve been working in the IT industry for over 20 years and one of the recurring themes continues to be the “end-to-end” versus “best-in-class” saga.

    Everyone seems to have an opinion, but until recently, you couldn’t love both.

    End-to-end versus best-in-class is an argument that lately came to the fore in procurement, where end-to-end solution means a complete suite across your entire procurement spectrum, from source-to-pay.

    The alternative is to select and invest in a best-in-class software (sometimes referred to as a “point” solution) to do each particular task or process on the spectrum, and then attempt to piece them all together.

     

    Spend Matters provided their insight into this debate. You can read more from them here!

     

    Procurement software is a major investment, and you will need to work with your IT department, possibly an external consultant to help you to make the right choice.

    You should take into account what you have now (your legacy systems) and upcoming investments in other areas and functions of the business.

    Consider the total cost of ownership, not just the upfront investment.

    When to go for Best-in-Class

    The main benefit of a best-in-class software solution is the depth of its functionality. Think of it as an inch wide and a mile deep.

    Because best-in-class software is hyper-focused on one area it offers robust capabilities and features to address specialized needs. That means it is absolutely essential that it should be capable of easy integration with other systems.

    The promise of vendors of best-in-class software solutions is that you can custom-build a software suite with exactly the solutions each area of your business needs, with focused functionality in every area.

    This is why they are often loved by end users. What they see is what they want. “I work in sourcing, so I want a sourcing solution.”

    On the other hand, depending on your organization and your industry, it’s possible that you may end up paying for mile-deep functionality when you really only need to dive down ten feet.

    A further argument in favor of best-in-class is that you can expand capabilities on your own terms.

    They are scalable so you can start with the software that addresses your most pressing area of need and then add additional capabilities when the time is right.

    For example, once you have sorted outsourcing, you look for the best specialist provider of contract management software.

    Rather than buying everything upfront, you can incorporate other best-in-class solutions as your business’s needs change and your budget allows.

    However, integration becomes more of an issue because each best-in-class system has its own data dictionary, data formats and other sources of incompatibility that can make seemingly simple integrations, difficult.

    And when it comes to several systems, the problems multiply.

    It’s likely that you will need to employ a specialist firm of systems integrators to make it work, and even then, the solution may be unstable, processes may not be streamlined, and visibility across all systems rather limited.

    When to go for End-to-End

    An end-to-end solution can fulfill every operational need for a specific business function, in this case procurement.

    Typically, this is thought of as a ‘mile wide and an inch deep’, but this isn’t really the case anymore.

    A study from Spend Matters shows that many end-to-end suites offer as good functionality or better than best-in-class providers!

    Companies that choose end-to-end solutions should pay attention to overlap in what the full-service solution offers compared to the solutions they already use.

    For example, ERP systems may already offer some limited procurement functionality that can be shifted to a source-to-pay implementation.

    A further advantage of an end-to-end solution is the avoidance of disputes between various point system vendors when things break down or go wrong, perhaps because there is no clean transfer of data between the contracts management system and the procurement system.

    With a source-to-pay implementation, you only have to deal with one support desk, no jumping around for fragmented answers.

    End-to-end software solutions should therefore be used when there is an obvious solution that can streamline processes and provide global visibility through the use of shared data.

    And that is increasingly the case these days as organizations seek to manage source-to-pay functionality holistically and seek to gain insights through spend analytics software to enable continuous improvements.

    End-to-end solutions can also be useful even when there is functionality overlap with existing solutions when the end-to-end software adds more value than existing point solutions or legacy systems like ERP.

    The Best of Both Worlds, and Finally, a Winner

    Since the advent and development of SaaS suites, you don’t have to choose between the two extremes.

    If you aren’t ready for the whole shebang, look for an end-to-end, source-to-pay but modular software solution, and invest in the modules that best suit your immediate needs.

    You can then expand your system horizontally, from the same supplier, so there are no integration issues.

    Some vendors, including JAGGAER, offer strong functionality and depth of expertise across the entire source-to-pay spectrum, often even better than the “best-in-class” providers.

    At the end of the day. What’s important is that you find the right solution for your organization’s needs. Doing your research and figuring out your long-term strategy is key.

    In my mind this debate has a clear winner, but you don’t have to take my word for it. You can read more in this free white paper from Spend Matter’s on the topic!

    Additional Resources

    Maturity Assessment

    Take this quick Autonomous Commerce Maturity Assessment now to identify your maturity stage and the next steps to take in your journey.