Blog

    Strategic Sourcing Best Practices – Proven Strategies for Procurement Success

    Strategic Sourcing Best Practices – Proven Strategies for Procurement Success

    Strategic Sourcing Simplified: Best Practices for Maximizing Value

    Strategic sourcing goes beyond cost savings—it’s about making informed decisions that drive long-term value. A successful approach requires careful assessment of supplier bids, followed by structured onboarding, continuous monitoring, and performance measurement. Now we’ll dive into best practices in these critical areas to ensure a more effective and resilient sourcing strategy.

    Assessing eAuction Bids

    eAuctions, or online sourcing events, have been around for more than twenty years and they have proven a highly effective tool for finding the best suppliers based on total cost.  

    When assessing bids following an eAuction, the process typically involves a combination of automated tools and human decision-making, especially when evaluating factors beyond just price. While automation can handle much of the basic analysis and decision-making, human involvement is still crucial for ensuring that the broader business requirements are met. It is here that best practices come to the fore! Here’s an outline of the thought process involved and how automation can play a role: 

    Automated Evaluation of Price Bids – After an eAuction, the first step in the assessment process is often the comparison of prices. Since reverse auctions focus heavily on price competitiveness, this can be easily done with sourcing software tools. They instantly compare bids based on predefined criteria, such as the lowest bid, pricing tiers, or total cost of ownership, and rank the suppliers accordingly. This helps quickly eliminate the subjectivity that could arise in manual pricing analysis. 

    Automation can also help calculate any discounts, volume-based pricing, or other financial incentives that may affect the final offer. This allows the procurement team to quickly identify the lowest or most favorable bid based on cost factors. 

    Qualification and Compliance Checks – Following the initial price assessment, the next step often involves evaluating whether the bids meet all the qualification criteria and compliance standards. Automation can also play a role here. For example, eSourcing software can automatically check whether the suppliers have met key regulatory requirements or quality standards, including certifications, insurance, and any other pre-defined qualifications set during the RFP stage. 

    Furthermore, eSourcing software can help review the contract terms and conditions against a predefined checklist to ensure there are no red flags, like missing clauses, discrepancies, or unfavorable terms. 

    Evaluating Non-Price Factors – Beyond price, there are often non-price factors that need to be considered, such as ESG, quality, delivery timelines, technical expertise, and supplier reputation. There is still scope for the software to throw some of these factors into the assessment. For example, carbon emissions can be costed, and delivery times or product quality might be scored numerically or based on predefined KPIs in the system. Historical data and AI-driven insights help optimize decision-making, allowing procurement teams to focus their expertise on more nuanced evaluations like supplier alignment with business strategy and customer service approach. 

    Supplier Risk Assessment – In an increasingly large number of cases, a detailed supplier risk assessment might be required to determine whether the lowest bidder is the best overall choice. This can include evaluating the supplier’s financial stability, past performance, capacity to meet demand, and potential risks related to geopolitical factors, supply chain issues, or sustainability. Automation can access data feeds from third parties, compiled from multiple sources (such as financial reports, news, or previous evaluations) to provide an informative risk profile. Then experienced procurement teams can assess all the data for more nuanced and context-specific judgments. 

    Negotiation & Contract Award – Once a supplier is selected, the process of finalizing the award and drawing up the contract begins. Contract management systems often play a role in this stage by helping to standardize and streamline the creation of contracts based on the awarded terms. These systems can automatically populate contract templates with data from the eAuction and RFP stages, ensuring consistency and reducing administrative burden. 

    While contracts software accelerates the process and minimizes errors, it also enhances human decision-making by providing real-time insights, flagging inconsistencies, and simplifying complex negotiations. Procurement teams can then focus on refining terms, addressing supplier concerns, and adapting agreements to evolving market conditions with greater efficiency and confidence. 

    Final Selection – While automation can handle repetitive tasks such as price comparisons, qualification checks, and compliance validation, human decision-makers remain essential for the final selection process. Factors like long-term strategic goals, supplier relationships, and reputation may not always be fully captured by automated tools. Moreover, the negotiation phase often involves delicate discussions around terms, risk allocation, and contingencies, which are better handled by human intelligence. 

    Best practices in the assessment of bids following an eAuction involve both automated processes and human input. Automation is highly effective for tasks like evaluating pricing, compliance, and basic contract management, while human decision-making is essential for evaluating complex, qualitative factors, and ensuring the supplier selection aligns with long-term strategic goals. This hybrid approach allows for a more efficient, transparent, and accurate sourcing process, leveraging sourcing and contract management technology for speed and scale while maintaining human oversight for critical decisions.

    Onboarding Suppliers

    Onboarding new suppliers and integrating them into the buyer’s supplier landscape can be a complex and laborious process involving several stages. While it may seem straightforward, many issues can arise, some of them entirely unseen if the process isn’t carefully managed.  

    • Misalignment of Expectations – One of the most common issues when engaging new suppliers is a misalignment of expectations between the buyer and supplier. This can occur in terms of delivery timelines, quality standards, pricing agreements, or overall service level expectations. If both parties aren’t on the same page from the outset, it can lead to misunderstandings, missed deadlines, or quality issues. 
      • Clear and thorough contract negotiation and a kick-off meeting to align expectations should bring both parties into alignment, ensuring a mutual understanding of requirements, timelines, and performance metrics.  
    • Lack of system integration – Another significant challenge is technical integration. New suppliers may need to connect with the buyer’s existing systems, such as enterprise resource planning (ERP), procurement, and inventory management systems. Disconnected systems can lead to inefficiencies, errors, delays, and data discrepancies. 
      • Buyers can standardize their systems and require suppliers to use compatible technologies. If integration is required, provide clear technical documentation and ensure that both parties have the necessary resources for a smooth data transfer process. Advanced supplier collaboration solutions allow seamless communication and data exchange to streamline integration, significantly reducing costs. 
    • Supplier Risk and Compliance Management – Bringing a new supplier onboard introduces risk, especially if they operate in a different geographical region or if they’ve not been thoroughly vetted. This risk can manifest itself as financial instability, supply chain disruptions, or non-compliance with regulatory standards, especially in industries with stringent compliance requirements (such as healthcare and financial services). Poorly managed onboarding can even put the entire payment chain at risk of vendor fraud or mistakes.  
      • It’s always best practice to conduct thorough due diligence during the sourcing process and prior to onboarding. This could include assessing the supplier’s financial health, reviewing their compliance certifications, and evaluating their ability to meet legal or ethical standards. It’s also wise to develop a risk management strategy that includes contingency plans for disruptions or non-compliance issues. 
    • Supplier Training and Knowledge Transfer – New suppliers may not be familiar with the buyer’s specific processes, systems, or quality expectations. Without adequate training, there can be gaps in performance, quality, and service delivery. The learning curve might also slow down the initial ramp-up period. 
      • Investing in supplier training before, during, and after onboarding is essential. This training should cover key areas such as company processes, product specifications, quality standards, order processes, and communication protocols. Regular check-ins and feedback loops during the initial stages of the relationship can help ensure that the supplier understands and aligns with the buyer’s expectations. 
    • Communication Breakdowns – Effective communication is essential to maintaining a strong supplier relationship. Poor communication can lead to missed orders, delayed shipments, misunderstandings regarding changes in demand, and even quality issues. New suppliers may struggle to adapt to the buyer’s preferred communication channels or may not respond in a timely manner, especially if they’re used to different processes or tools. 
      • Establish clear communication protocols from the start. This includes defining how often updates will be provided, what kind of reporting is expected, and who the main points of contact are on both sides. Using a shared collaboration platform or supplier portal can also streamline communication and reduce misunderstandings. 
    • Cultural and Operational Differences – When dealing with international suppliers, cultural differences can also pose challenges. These might include differing attitudes towards timelines, decision-making processes, negotiation styles, or work ethics. Operational practices may also differ, leading to inefficiencies or conflicts down the road. 
      • Understand and respect cultural differences early on. Providing suppliers with a comprehensive onboarding manual, including expectations about communication, work practices, and business norms, can help bridge any cultural gaps. Moreover, fostering cross-cultural training and building a relationship based on trust can minimize potential conflicts and misunderstandings. 
    • Lack of (Or Poor) Supplier Performance Monitoring – Once the supplier is onboard, a buying organization needs to track and monitor performance to ensure that they are meeting agreed-upon standards. Without ongoing monitoring, issues such as quality deterioration, delayed shipments, or missed service levels can go unnoticed, potentially leading to larger problems down the line. 
      • Implement a robust supplier performance management program such as JAGGAER Supply Chain Collaboration. This includes regularly monitoring KPIs, setting up periodic reviews, and maintaining a system for feedback. It’s also useful to establish early warning systems to detect any potential issues before they become major problems. 
    • Inefficient Onboarding Process – A lengthy and manual onboarding process can delay the integration of a new supplier and may result in inefficiencies or unnecessary friction. If paperwork, compliance checks, or other formalities take too long, it can stall the supplier’s ability to start fulfilling orders or integrating effectively into the buyer’s supply chain. In short, delays in onboarding mean delayed time to value with the new supplier.
      • Streamlining the onboarding process through digitalization is a major benefit. Using supplier onboarding platforms that automate document submission, approval workflows, and data collection helps speed up the process. Additionally, having a structured, well-documented onboarding plan and clear timelines helps ensure that no steps are missed. Onboarding suppliers from the JAGGAER Supplier Network is especially simple and efficient. Because thousands of suppliers already work with JAGGAER customers, the onboarding process is quick and easy.  

    Successfully onboarding and integrating a new supplier requires thoughtful planning and proactive risk management. By establishing clear expectations, facilitating technical integration, providing adequate training, and fostering strong communication from the outset, new supplier engagement can be smooth and efficient. Leveraging technology for automation, performance monitoring, and communication helps create a more efficient and scalable process.

    Additional Resources